Pushpin help!

[kiwi.livejournal.com]

Okay, ladies, I need some help.

I have a biiiiiiig bulletin board that has been given to me and is covered with multicolored pushpins. (I think they're pushpins...not the flat ones but the ones with the "body" so you can remove them with ease and without killing your fingernails?) I like multi-colored just as much as the next person, but they just don't go with the rest of my decor.

I have plans to cover the bulletin board with wrapping paper that matches my decor (because cork is just not that pretty) and really don't feel bright green and red pushpins would match the muted tones I usually use.

How can I change their appearance? I'm not looking to do marbles (I've got marble magnets already, don't want to overkill that), I'm just looking to do anything to them to make them match my soon-to-be-newly-wrapped bulletin board. Functional is good. Functional and durable is better.

Any/all suggestions will be taken into serious consideration. Thank you!!!